Latest dealsDeals See all deals→
From the collection Save Point Rituals curated by Chloe · 4 pieces
Follow collectionOpen collection
Gaming

Watching Someone Else Play

The thing I remember first is not the game but the chair. It was a dining chair dragged into the living room because there was no room left on the sofa, one leg wrapped with a strip of tape that made a soft sticking sound every time I shifted my weight. My friend Mara was on the floor in front of the television, knees up, controller in both hands, making her careful way through a horror game I had already finished. The room was lit almost entirely by the game itself, that blue-grey light games use when they want every corridor to feel damp and faintly offended by your presence. On the coffee table there was a bowl of pistachio shells and one untouched clementine that had rolled into the remote.

I was not playing. I had no intention of playing. I had come over, as we both understood, to watch.

This is a kind of gaming relationship I care about very much, and because it produces no save file with my name on it and no neat record of what I did, I think it gets underrated. We are comfortable praising cooperation when two people each have a controller, or skill when someone performs for an audience online, but the ordinary business of being the person beside the player can seem like dead time. I have never found it dead. It asks for a specific sort of attention. You have to notice what the player notices, and also what they are missing. You have to decide when to speak. You have to learn the exact difference between useful help and intolerable help.

Mara plays slowly, which I mean as praise. She opens drawers. She reads notes. If a game has bottles on a shelf, she will inspect the bottles as if one of them might contain the whole thesis. I play more like someone late for an appointment. Even in games I love, I can feel a little engine inside me pushing toward the next objective marker, the next upgrade, the next proof that I am not wasting time. Watching Mara is one of the few situations in which that engine goes quiet. I stop wanting progress in my usual way. I begin wanting style.

That night I knew where the jump scares were. I knew which locked door would open from the other side later, and that the expensive ammunition should be saved, and that the family in the framed photographs mattered less than the game wanted us to think. Knowledge, in this setup, is not power so much as a temptation. It sits on your tongue and asks to be useful. My brother and I, growing up, had rough household rules for this. If it was not your turn, you could warn, suggest, or laugh, but you were not allowed to grab. You were not allowed to narrate somebody else's hands. The controller creates a tiny sovereignty. Once I had words for it, I realized I respected this rule beyond childhood. Watching someone else play means accepting that your superior information may have no rights at all.

Mara got to a room with a generator puzzle I hated the first time. There were switches, a time limit, one enemy whose footsteps sounded much closer than they were, and a note in the corner that existed mainly to distract you. I sat forward on the taped chair. She stood still and listened to the room, not because the game required it but because she likes to take a space's measure before she acts. Then she ignored the note, tried the sequence I knew was wrong, laughed when the lights failed, and said, "Well, now we know one thing." It was such a modest sentence, but it changed the atmosphere at once. Failure, in her hands, became information instead of embarrassment.

Watching someone else play shows you their tolerance for uncertainty better than almost anything. You learn whether they mash buttons under pressure or become strangely elegant. You learn if they hoard healing items as if preparing for a famine or spend them freely because relief now is worth more than hypothetical need later. You learn if they trust maps. You learn if they can leave a side room unexplored. These are not deep truths in the grand personality-test sense, and I distrust any claim that games reveal who we really are. But they do reveal habits of approach. They show the little manners we bring to confusion.

I think this is one reason I love being a backseat navigator in role-playing games especially. When someone else is doing the walking, the fighting, the inventory management, I become the steward of other things. I remember names. I keep track of factions. I say, wasn't that crest on the letter from two towns ago? I become the person whose attention is not occupied by survival and can therefore afford to care about whatever is hanging at the edges. I have sat beside people for whole evenings saying things like, no, talk to the woman by the fountain again, she mentioned a brother, and feeling absurdly satisfied when it mattered. This is not a lesser participation. It is simply participation that has specialized.

My father, who does not really play games except in the broad family sense of having occasionally joined in and mostly watched, used to stand in the doorway when my brother and I were stuck on something and offer exactly one suggestion, often from a position of only partial understanding. Sometimes it was useless. Sometimes it was irritatingly correct. What I remember now is not his accuracy but his confidence that watching counted as involvement. He would ask who that character was, what the objective was, why we kept falling in the same pit, and then after a while he would become invested enough to wince at a missed jump. There are households where television becomes background and there are households where somebody passing through stops and gets caught by the shape of a problem on the screen. Ours, luckily for me, was often the second kind.

That inheritance matters more to my taste than I used to admit. I like games that can withstand company. I do not mean only games with local multiplayer, though I love those. I mean games legible enough, or textured enough, that another person can enter by looking. A good watching game has pauses in it. It has enough visual or narrative information that a newcomer can form opinions after ten minutes. It allows for commentary without collapsing. Some games turn to sludge when observed from the side. Others become richer because someone is there to notice your methods, tease your cowardice, or remember the clue you ignored while busy trying not to die.

Mara reached the puzzle's last switch with the enemy finally close enough to force the issue. She panicked in a very orderly way, which is another quality I admire. She circled a table, missed the prompt twice, healed too early, then got the generator running with a sliver of health left. I cheered as if I had done any of it. We both laughed at the same stupid line of dialogue afterward, the kind games mistake for human speech. Then she handed me the clementine because she could not peel it one-handed during the next cutscene.

Some of my most vivid game memories are like this and belong, strictly speaking, to somebody else. I remember a boss fight I never touched because I was the one timing dodges out loud. I remember an entire detective game mostly as the sound of my friend saying, wait, go back, that man is lying, and being right. I remember sitting on the carpet while my brother, years ago, attempted the same difficult platforming section over and over, and my role slowly changed from witness to metronome. Jump, pause, jump. We were both irritated by the level. Only one of us was holding the controller, but the rhythm became shared.

There is a version of taste that treats authorship as the only serious form of engagement. You must cook, not just eat. You must make the playlist, not just listen. You must be the one steering or your presence is somehow passive. I do not believe this about games. Spectatorship in a living room is not the same as watching a stream with thousands of other people, and it is not the same as idly glancing up from your phone while someone else does the interesting bit. It is closer to conversation under pressure. Two people look at the same problem from slightly different angles, and one of them has thumbs free enough to think in full sentences.

What surprises me, when I try to say why I cherish this, is that the pleasure is not mainly about access to a game I might not play myself. It is about proximity to another person's style. Left alone, I can become managerial with games. I optimize. I fuss. I move too quickly past anything that does not obviously pay out. Watching someone else, especially someone I trust, gives me back a wider sense of what play can look like. It reminds me that hesitation can be a style. So can curiosity. So can cowardice used intelligently. So can stopping in the middle of a dangerous hallway because the wallpaper seems worth a closer look.

By the end of the evening Mara had made less progress than I would have in the same number of hours, and we had had a better time than I often do alone. We talked over clues, argued gently about whether a locked cabinet was decorative or suspicious, and built a tiny shared vocabulary for the game's nonsense. At one point she handed me the controller only to navigate a menu because she hates crafting interfaces, then took it back the moment the character started moving again. It felt right, almost ceremonial, like passing a bowl across the table and receiving it back.

When I left, the dining chair was still in the wrong room and the clementine peel was drying into itself on a napkin. Nothing had been achieved that could be shown to anyone except a little more of the map and a little more of how Mara plays under stress. But that seems to me plenty. Games are full of scenes designed to prove what the person with the controller can do. I have become attached to the quieter proof available beside them, which is that attention can be shared without being equal, and still feel companionable, and still count.

More from Save Point Rituals

All 4 pieces →

More collections

All collections →