Latest dealsDeals See all deals→
From the collection Screen Time, Kept curated by Henry Martin · 4 pieces
Follow collectionOpen collection
TechnologyMental Health

The Route Decides

The voice said, in its patient bright tone, to bear left where I would usually have gone straight. I was driving across town to pick up a lamp my partner had found secondhand, and I had the phone clipped to the vent, the map enlarged so that each instruction arrived with the confidence of a person who had already done the journey. The road ahead was one I knew, or had once known, but the app had seen a red line somewhere further on and was moving me around it. I put on the indicator and obeyed.

The turn took me through a string of residential streets I would never have chosen for myself. They were narrow and lined with cars on both sides, with clipped hedges and small front gardens and the occasional football goal folded against a fence. It was the sort of route that feels faintly apologetic even when it is legal, as if one has been let into the back passages of a place built for other people’s routines. A man was bringing in his bins. A woman in running clothes waited to cross with a terrier that looked offended by the drizzle. I drove at twenty miles an hour and felt, with a kind of mild embarrassment, that I had arrived in somebody else’s paragraph.

What struck me was not that I had been diverted. It was how little of the city I needed, in that moment, to understand. I did not need to know what neighborhood I was in, or what the road would become two miles later, or which river crossing we were avoiding, or whether there was a better bakery one street over. I only needed the next instruction. A city can now be taken in spoonfuls.

I learned to drive before a phone could do this for me. Not heroically early, just early enough to have had a glove compartment full of folded paper and to remember the private drama of pulling over to work out where I had gone wrong. I used to keep an atlas in the car with its plasticized cover cracking at the corners. If I was visiting somewhere unfamiliar, I would study the route before leaving, tracing it with a finger, trying to hold in my head three or four major turns like a short speech I meant to deliver without notes. You did not memorize every street, only the shape of the journey. Bridge, roundabout, ring road, second exit, church on the left, then ask somebody if the house numbers had become peculiar.

I do not miss getting lost in any simple way. It was often irritating, sometimes expensive, and occasionally the sort of mistake that made me arrive with a pulse still running ahead of me. I have no romance about circling a one-way system while trying to read a sign at the same time. There are journeys for which turn-by-turn directions feel like an uncomplicated mercy. Driving somewhere at night in heavy rain, looking for a hospital entrance, or finding a rental cottage at the end of a lane after a train delay, I have been sincerely grateful for the calm female voice that says to continue for two miles and means it. The relief is practical and real. It is one of the better things phones do.

But the relief has a cost that is difficult to notice because it arrives disguised as ease. I have lived in this city for years. There are districts I can describe by feel more readily than by name, and there are roads I used to know through repetition that I now submit back to the phone as if they were new to me each time. I have outsourced not only the finding of places but the keeping of them.

This becomes obvious when the route fails. A few months ago I was driving to meet a friend at a pub on the far side of town, one I had been to before, though not recently. Halfway there I took a call through the car speakers from my brother, who was standing outside a station with a cancelled train and wanted to know whether changing at another stop would strand him even more thoroughly. In the small confusion of talking and driving, the phone slipped out of its mount and landed face down on the passenger seat. By the time I could pull over, the screen had gone dark and the map had closed itself back into the ordinary busyness of the home screen. I was less than ten minutes from where I needed to be. I could picture the pub sign. I could not have told you, with any confidence, how to reach it.

I sat at the curb, engine idling, and felt a disproportionate annoyance, as if I had been interrupted in the middle of being led by the hand. Then I recognized the deeper irritation underneath. I was not really angry at the interruption. I was angry at my own shallowness of knowledge. The route had been happening to me, and because it had been happening so smoothly I had mistaken that for knowing it.

My partner is better at this than I am. She will often glance at the map before leaving and then put the phone away, especially if she is walking. She says she dislikes becoming the sort of person who stands at a corner waiting to be told whether to turn left. When we travel somewhere new together, she notices the names of streets and the color of a building and the small square with the fountain in the middle. I notice the blue line. If I am alone, I can walk through an unfamiliar area while barely lifting my eyes except to avoid collision, my attention narrowed to a sequence of confirmations: yes, here, now there, recalculating, proceed.

Walking may be where the change is strongest. In a car, at least, roads arrive in larger pieces. On foot, navigation can reduce a place to a set of corrections. I have followed the phone through cities I ought to remember and come away with almost nothing that could help me return except a thin confidence that the device could do it again. Once, in Lisbon, I realized over dinner that I could not have retraced our afternoon walk to save myself. I remembered a tiled wall, a tram, a bakery with custard tarts in the window, but not their order, not the incline of the streets, not the logic of how one neighborhood became another. The day had been pleasant. It had not adhered.

This would matter less if navigation only replaced memory. But it also changes the kind of mistake I make. Before, I might have missed a turning because I had misunderstood the map or overestimated my own sense of direction. The errors were mine and usually legible afterwards. I can still remember taking the wrong bridge in Birmingham years ago and spending twenty minutes correcting it, because I had made an assumption about where the ring road would spit me out. That mistake taught me something, if only humility. Now the mistakes are often stranger. They are acts of trust misplaced at speed.

The lamp errand ended in one of those. The app’s shortcut delivered me to a lane that narrowed into parked vans, then into temporary traffic lights, then into a queue behind a refuse lorry performing its slow and rightful work. I could see on the map that I was technically making progress. In lived time, I was not. The main road, the one I had almost taken before the voice redirected me, would by then have cleared after the school-run knot that had first alarmed the app. I was trapped in the efficiency of a calculation made two minutes too early.

When I finally arrived, the seller helped me fit the lamp into the back seat and said, in the local way of people who know what roads are for, “You didn’t come through Alder Street, did you? They’ve got lights there.” I told him no, the app had sent me around. He laughed and said, “Round is worse.” It was such a simple sentence that I kept it with me on the drive home. Round is worse. Not always, of course. Often round is better. But a local knowledge had been compressed, in that remark, into something the route had not been able to feel: the difference between a delay on a road built to absorb delay and a delay on a lane that clogs at the sight of a delivery van.

There is a democratic promise in the map on the phone. It gives strangers access to competence. It lets me arrive in places where once I might have hesitated to go, or would have left absurdly early, anxious about junctions. It has made certain kinds of confidence available to almost anyone with a battery charge. I would not want to give that up. Yet I notice that the confidence is oddly external. It lives in the system more than in me.

Sometimes, when I am walking somewhere familiar enough, I now leave the directions off and see what remains. This is not a grand test, only a small one. Can I get to the dentist from the station without checking? Do I remember the back way to the cinema that avoids the busiest crossing? Which side street leads to the good greengrocer, and which one only feels as if it should? The exercise is slightly embarrassing in the way all recoveries are. I find there are parts of my own area that I know only as obedient movements once cued.

What returns first is not mastery but texture. Without the blue line, I notice where the pavement narrows by the locksmith, where one row of plane trees begins, where the smell from the bakery arrives half a block before the shopfront itself. I remember that one route is quicker but ugly, and another takes thirty seconds longer and passes the small garden square where someone, every spring, puts out pots of tulips in extravagant reds. These are not efficient facts. They do not help software. They are the kind that make a place stick.

On the way back with the lamp, I ignored the first suggestion and took the main road. Traffic moved slowly for a stretch, exactly as the app had predicted it would. Then it opened. I passed the library, the tyre place, the pub with the hanging baskets that are too ambitious for the season, and the turn for the park where my partner had once stopped for coffee after going to the hardware store, a small detour I knew about not because the map told me but because she later mentioned it. By the time I reached our street, I had spent longer in the car than the route originally promised. I had also, in some modest way, been present for where I was.

More from Screen Time, Kept

All 4 pieces →

More collections

All collections →