Making your own candles is one of those fun DIY projects that feels super rewarding, especially when you get to personalise them with your favourite scents and colours. However, before you get started pouring wax into any of your cute containers, you need to make an extremely important decision: Which wax should I use – soy wax or coconut wax? If you’ve ever found yourself confused between these two, then you're certainly at the right place. Both are natural, plant-based options that are way better for the environment than regular paraffin wax. Before starting, it’s also a good idea to clean your containers and tools with isopropyl alcohol to remove dust and oils for better adhesion and smoother results. Keep reading to know which wax is the best fit for your DIY candle-making adventures!
What Is Soy Wax?
Soy wax comes from soybean oil and is processed into flakes, which makes it very convenient to work with (particularly for container candles). Soy wax burns quite slowly and evenly, it’s not as long-lasting as coconut wax. But it’s still a good solid choice, especially if you want a more affordable option. When comparing the melting point of soy wax to that of other waxes, soy has a relatively low melting point making it a popular choice for jar candles.
What Is Coconut Wax?
Coconut wax, on the other hand, is made from coconut oil that’s been specially processed to turn it into a solid wax. This process helps increase the melting point, making it easier to handle and giving it a smooth, creamy look. One of the coolest things about coconut wax is that it holds onto fragrance really well, meaning your candles will smell amazing. Plus, they burn for a super long time, which is always a win when you want your candle to last.
Differences Between Coconut Wax and Soy Wax
When you’re deciding between soy wax vs coconut wax, you’ll want to keep a few things in mind:
1. Soot Emission
Nobody wants to light a candle that leaves black soot floating around the room. The good news is that both soy wax and coconut wax burn much cleaner than traditional paraffin wax, which is what you’ll find in most store-bought candles. Soy wax is especially popular for clean burning because it produces very little soot when made properly with the right wick. Coconut wax can burn slightly cleaner in some cases, but the difference is very small and usually not that noticeable in everyday use. For most homes, soy wax burn more cleanly and create a nice, smooth and even burn while keeping the air relatively clean at the same time.
2. Toxicity
Paraffin candles are traditionally the most popular candle choice, yet soy wax and coconut wax have gained popularity for any reasons. Both are non-toxic and give much cleaner burning. Soy wax is widely trusted for home use and, when paired with the right wick, burns cleanly with very minimal soot. Coconut wax can burn slightly cleaner, but in real-world use, soy wax performs extremely well and is considered a safe, reliable option for everyday candles. In short, both soy wax and coconut wax are considerably healthier choices than paraffin.
3. Burn Time
Everyone prefers long-lasting candles. Soy wax burns slowly and evenly, which is why it’s quite popular for container candles. It gives a consistent burn and a steady scent with no tunnelling. Coconut wax can burn a bit longer, but most people won't see a marked difference. Soy wax still offers a solid burn time, especially when you’re making candles regularly or in larger batches which makes it a practical and dependable choice.
4. Melting Point
Soy wax stands out due to its melting point. Soy wax has a higher melting point than coconut wax, which allows it to hold its shape better in warmer temperatures. Therefore, soy wax is suited for candles that may be shipped, stored or used in the warmer months. Coconut wax is softer and melts more easily which is why it’s often blended. Soy wax adds structure and stability, making candle-making easier and more predictable.
5. Scent Throw
Both waxes hold fragrance well. However, they release fragrances differently. While coconut wax has a very strong scent throw, soy wax offers a balanced and smooth fragrance release. Soy wax is the best type of wax to use for everyday candles because it won't overwhelm you and is useful when making candles in larger quantities, where consistency and subtle scent performance matter more than intensity.
6. Price
Cost is often the deciding factor. Soy wax is more affordable because soybeans are widely available and are also easier to produce. Therefore, it is a favourite for DIY makers and small businesses. Coconut wax is more expensive, so it’s often used in blends. If you’re looking for quality, performance as well as value, soy wax offers the best balance without compromising on cleanliness or burn quality.
Which One is Better? Soy Wax vs Coconut Wax
After examining all the details, you're probably wondering: Which one is better? Well, it depends on what you're looking for in your candles.
Choose coconut wax if you want a long burn time, cleaner burns with less soot, and more scent throw. Coconut Wax is ideal for smaller batches or candles you want to last a long time.
Choose soy wax if you'd like a more affordable option, while providing a clean burn and lasting a decent amount of time. Soy wax works well for larger candle-making projects, especially if you're planning on making lots of candles in jars.
Final Thoughts
When it comes down to soy vs coconut wax, the difference lies in what you want. Both are natural & eco-friendly alternatives for DIY Candle Making. Coconut Wax offers a longer burning time & stronger fragrance, whereas Soy Wax may be a good fit if you're looking for something cheaper (in terms of cost & availability) and/or plan to create many candles at once.
And if you want the best balance of performance, stability, and scent, a coconut-soy blend like CocoSoy C-6 from AMC Supplies is a fantastic solution.
FAQs
1. Is soy wax safe to use at home?
Yes, soy wax is non-toxic and burns cleanly when used with the right wick and which makes it safe for everyday home use.
2. Does soy wax produce black soot?
Soy wax produces very little soot as compared to paraffin candles, so it helps keep your air and walls cleaner.
3. Which wax is better for beginners?
Soy wax is great for beginners because it’s easy to melt, pour, and also gives consistent results in container candles.
4. Does soy wax hold fragrance well?
Yes, soy wax holds fragrance nicely and releases scent smoothly without being too strong or even overpowering.
5. Why is soy wax more affordable than coconut wax?
Soy wax is made from widely grown soybeans, which makes it easier to produce and more budget-friendly.
Sign in to leave a comment.